Quantcast

Betty's Blog

Timely Teacher Talk

Sponsored Links

Will work for money

If students won't work for the joy of a job well done, some schools are offering hard cash for improving test scores.

Students in Baltimore can receive as much as $110 each if they buckle down and improve their scores on state graduation exams, and New York City is dangling a carrot worth approximately $500 to about 9,000 fourth and seventh graders if they can do better on English and math tests.

In suburban Atlanta, a pair of schools last week kicked off a program that will pay 8th- and 11th-grade students $8 an hour for a 15-week "Learn & Earn" after-school study program (the federal minimum wage is currently $5.85).

In most cases, the efforts are funded privately through corporate or philanthropic donors.

The most ambitious experiment began in September, when seven states — Arkansas, Alabama, Connecticut, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Virginia and Washington — won spots in an Exxon/Mobil-funded program that, in most cases, pays students $100 for each passing grade on advanced placement (AP) college-prep exams.

Regardless of the amount of money or the prizes offered, it's sad to think that schools have to resort to paying students to raise their test scores.  I frequently watch children beam and glow when they receive specific praise after completing an assignment.  The praise itself puts a smile on their faces.

Sure, it's exciting to think about earning a bit of extra money.  What happens the next year if the money isn't available?  What about those kids who are already doing a great job?  Will they lower their standards so they can qualify to get some cash? 

Schools paying kids for test scores seems like a bad idea to me.

Obverse of the Series 2003A $100 bill

 

 

Posted: Sunday, September 07, 2008 4:15 PM by Betty
Comments

MysteryTeacher said:

Wow!  I agree.  I tell the kids that their job is school and their pay is the grade.  I think schools giving kids money to do the job they are supposed to is not very attractive.  Kids need to learn that not everything in this world is going to receive a cash benefit.  Some things we do are supposed to be intrinsic.

# September 7, 2008 5:47 PM

Gina said:

I actually did tell my son that if he proved he was responsible and did well his first marking period he could have a fish.  I guess that's similar however I don't think I'd feel comfortable with the school giving my child money at all.  It would be nice to see the money instead converted into future scholarship opportunity credits but to just hand over cash just seems odd.  Besides, what if that money is then used to buy something not so scholarly or worse something illegal.  

# September 7, 2008 6:36 PM

Pebbles said:

I'm at a district here in Texas and we were told that we couldn't give ANY incentives related to their TAKS test or scores.  This included pizza parties, pencils, good luck pennies, etc.  That just seems so foreign that districts would offer money!!

# September 8, 2008 10:56 AM

Stacey said:

Makes me sick to think that we're paying kids off for doing well.  What happens to the kids who make progress for them, but not AYP as defined by the school district?  Is that fair?

# September 8, 2008 9:33 PM

John said:

I don't see this type of program being a good solution for producing academic improvement. At first, some may show initial improvement because of interest in financial gain, but that won't solve the root problem(s) that caused the low grades. It does not address any learning disabilities or difficulties, for one thing. And, if the poor performance is related to attitude or effort, can adding money improve character? I don't think so in the long run.

# September 9, 2008 2:30 PM

brazenteacher said:

Hey I say if you're going to do something- then do it 100 percent! We already put our Pretty Green Paper above most other facets of life. Let's go for Gold! Show those kiddos how to really embrace the superficiality of life- and all that goes with it. Yeah!

# September 11, 2008 9:19 PM
New Comments to this post are disabled.