Quantcast

Betty's Blog

Timely Teacher Talk

Sponsored Links

My Lesson Plans

    Two wrongs sure don't make it right

    The Social Security numbers of some kindergarten children in Texas are being given to a private company for the purpose of storing reading scores.  Two wrongs occur to me here: Possible identity theft and funds used to create data bases for five and six year olds.

    Texas school districts are handing over Social Security numbers, dates of birth and other sensitive information about the state's kindergarten students to a private software company without permission from the children's parents.

    State education officials who set up the unusual arrangement insist that the information is safe. But some educators and parents worry about sending student Social Security numbers to a private company hired to store kindergarten reading test scores.

    OZ Systems, an Arlington software company, has received at least $2.3 million in state money to create databases of preschool and kindergarten student records.

    Take a breath.  That seems like a lot of money to me.  I'm thinking that much money could go a long way towards educating young children instead of storing and analyzing data. 

    Anyone who has ever been around young children knows that they all learn at different rates.  Some kids are just ready to read sooner than others.  It's kind of like talking and potty training.  Children will do things when they are ready.

    I'm not saying that reading shouldn't be taught and encouraged in kindergarten, but spending money to keep up with test scores from this age group just seems silly.   My son admitted to me that he just "filled in the bubbles" on a reading test in second grade.  I confronted him when I received a rather alarming call from the school.  He took another form of the test and did okay after realizing that his guessing strategy had caused his teacher and his mother a great deal of stress.

    How accurate are these tests that are being stored using the Social Security numbers of children?  In today's world where we all worry about identity theft, is this really necessary?  Maybe there could be a better use of $2.3 million dollars!

    Posted: Thursday, January 17, 2008 8:47 AM by Betty

    Comments

    MysteryTeacher said:

    It occurs to me that besides Idenity theft, what about someone breaking in and corrupting the information.  They could change scores and make their child or children have higher scores than they really do.  Getting into college is becoming a long term plan-ahead.  I am old fashioned enough to wonder what people are up to.  I have seen so much cheating here at school among students, parents and some teachers that it no longer surprises me.  I don't trust them much.  We have parents tell us their child tested gifted and they want them in a program and when we get the records, they did not test gifted.  Others don't tell us their child is in resource and we wonder and begin the Child Study process and then later after all the paper work and meetings, we find out they already had an IEP but the parents were hoping that we wouldn't find out.  Unless we request the special ed records separate, the school cannot send them to us or us to them.  That is rediculous!  All records on a child should follow them to the new location.  Even and especially discipline records.

    # January 17, 2008 9:13 AM

    Pebbles said:

    Is there a list of participating schools?  Or are ALL Texas districts required to submit their numbers?  I'd like to know if my kindergartener's school is doing this!  

    # January 17, 2008 10:24 AM

    Betty said:

    I have heard that some districts might not be participating.  You'd probably have to call the administration building and ask them.

    # January 17, 2008 11:51 AM

    tyme2teach said:

    I am not from Texas, but I can not believe this is happening. I agree with Pebbles, I would want to know if my child's SS# is going to be submitted. With many types of accounts, often we are asked if we want any of our personal information sold or forwarded to other agencies.  You'd think the school system would be sharing this information with their parents, before releasing.  I would be contacting my Congressman,local news papers,and new stations right about now.

    # January 20, 2008 12:54 PM

    mz.w said:

    hard data on pre-school and kindergarten??? waste of money, not to mention the SS# issue...people don't know when to stop. NCLB made so much more sense to me once i found out one of bush's cronies is a textbook/test publisher...

    # January 25, 2008 12:16 AM
    New Comments to this post are disabled.